Optimal Pedagogy

By Jeremy Nixon

Foundations of the Next Generation Education System


Optimal Pedagogy

Why Optimal Pedagogy?

A ruthless distillation of the most effective learning techniques for autodidacts and educators.

This is an attempt to write down the best possible body of pragmatic psychotechnology for autodidacts, teaching & founding a next-generation education system on a ruthless representation of the most effective tactics.

52 practices were considered and stripped down to my conception of the 10 with the most cognitive leverage, best performing on time-result-generality frontier. All ten work for in almost every context, have fantastic time-to-improvement ratios when invested in, and when integrated as the basis of a learning system have the highest hope of generating phenomenal minds.

38 books, lectures and articles on how to learn were considered, of which I highly recommend 9.The fuller list of practices and resources is included under "Additional Pedagogy Candidates" and "Extended Metalearning Curriculum".

Bloom's Two Sigma

Tutoring + Mastery Learning (Prerequisite Mastery).

Bloom's Two Sigma graph showing achievement distributions
Blooms 2 Sigma. Source: https://www.classcentral.com/report/blooms-2-sigma-problem/

In the paradoxical manner that truth often wears the mask of absurdity, Benjamin Bloom's "Two Sigma" phenomenon presents us with an educational miracle that is at once blindingly obvious and stubbornly neglected.

Bloom found that if you do two simple things - provide one-on-one tutoring (that's one sigma) and make sure students fully master each concept before moving to the next (that's mastery learning) - almost every student performs extraordinarily better, about two standard deviations better! That's like taking an average student and boosting them to the 98th percentile.

This is not merely a statistical curiosity, but a thunderous proclamation that ordinary children might achieve extraordinary results, if only we would arrange education according to the natural laws of learning rather than the artificial constraints of industrial efficiency.

Feynman Technique

Teach someone else the content, forcing you to frame information from a different perspective.

Feynman Technique illustration
Source: https://medium.com/illumination/the-danger-of-the-feynman-technique-50fa3863fdfb

In teaching, we find ourselves forced to abandon the comfortable fog of half-knowledge, those shadowy realms where we nod sagely at complex terms while secretly harboring confusion. Instead, explain things in the simplest possible way, cutting fog into clarity.

Pick something you want to understand. Could be quantum electrodynamics or how a toaster works - doesn't matter.

Try explaining it to a 12-year-old. Not a real one necessarily - imagine you're talking to a smart kid who doesn't know the jargon. If you catch yourself using fancy words or handwaving through parts, stop! That's a red flag that you don't really understand that bit.

When you hit those gaps in your understanding - and you will, we all do - go back to your books or notes and fill in those holes. Keep working until you can explain the whole thing in simple language.

Finally, simplify and use analogies. If your explanation is clunky, streamline it. Find analogies that connect to things people already understand.

The wonderful thing about this approach is that it's a feedback loop - you learn something, try to explain it, discover what you don't know, learn some more, explain again... and pretty soon, you've got it wired into your brain in a way that's rock solid.

Remember, if you can't explain something simply, you don't understand it well enough yet. And that's okay! That's how you know what to work on next.

Deliberate Practice

Focus on the parts of content that are difficult & increase intensity of practice / focus.

Deliberate Practice illustration
Source: https://www.practica-learning.com/deliberate-practice

Let's take playing the violin. A regular person might just play songs over and over. But someone using deliberate practice would isolate the difficult parts – maybe a tricky fingering pattern – and work on just that small section, slowly at first, getting feedback from a teacher, gradually increasing the tempo. They'd record themselves and listen critically. They'd compare their sound to masters.

The key ingredients:

Here's a secret most people miss: deliberate practice isn't fun in the usual sense. It's challenging. Sometimes it's frustrating. You're deliberately focusing on what you can't do well yet!

So if you want to get really good at something – I mean really good – you can't just put in the hours. You have to put in the right kind of hours. Break it down, focus intensely, get feedback, push your limits, and repeat.

Read & Re-Write

After reading material, look away from the material and recall it (writing or verbal). Repeat for great effect.

Read and Re-Write illustration
Source: https://languagedrops.com/blog/writing-can-help-you-learn-a-language

When I was reading the Deep Learning Textbook, rewriting every section in my own words was crucial to long term, high quality retention. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KtLsLnMWIZIvb2hbOMrp_ZTocvaaLPJhgOHTkNyeAN0/edit?tab=t.0

Let me tell you what happens. You read a page in one of a fancy textbook filled with equations, and you think, "Yeah, I got it." But then you close the book and—poof!—it's gone. That's not understanding at all!

What really works is this: read something, then put the book down and write it down—in your own words, as if you're teaching it to someone who's never heard of it before.

There are multiple reasons:

Application

Use learned knowledge in a project, ideally creating something new from first principles.

Application of knowledge illustration

You haven't really learned something until you've used it to make something new. That's the simple truth of it.

The principle applies to any knowledge. If you've just learned about differential equations, don't just solve the problems at the end of the chapter. Try to model something real—maybe the spread of a disease, or the cooling of a cup of coffee. Start with the simplest version and build up.

When you apply knowledge, especially from first principles, several magical things happen:

First, you discover the *practical* gaps in your understanding immediately. There's no hiding from them. When your program crashes or your bridge model collapses, you know exactly where your knowledge is incomplete.

Second, you form connections between this new knowledge and things you already know. These connections are the real gold—they're what turn isolated facts into a web of understanding.

Third, you remember it far better. Our brains are wired to remember things we've actively used, especially when there were consequences (even just the consequence of whether your project worked or not).

The best applications are creative ones. Don't just follow a recipe or tutorial—modify it, extend it, combine it with something else. Ask "what if?" questions. What if I tried this approach instead? What if I combined these two techniques? What if I applied this math to a completely different domain?

And start simple. You don't need to build a fusion reactor to apply your physics knowledge. Start with a small project that you can complete, then build on it. Each success gives you confidence and deeper understanding for the next challenge.

Material as Important as Method

Ensure content is incremental and represents the vital 20% that delivers 80% of understanding.

Pareto principle illustration for learning materials
Source: dev.to

The reason so many of your learning experiments fail is you're *using the wrong material*.

Answer two questions: What resource will you love to learn from? And what resource is at *exactly* the right level of difficulty for you to be both gratified and challenged?

The material should be properly sequenced and incremental. You can't learn calculus before algebra, and you can't learn to run before you can walk. Each new piece should build on what came before, with just the right amount of challenge—not so easy that you're bored, not so hard that you're lost.

Focus on the vital foundations. In almost any field, roughly 20% of the concepts will give you 80% of the power. Identify that critical 20% and master it thoroughly before worrying about the rest.

For example, if you're learning programming, understanding variables, functions, loops, and conditionals will let you build surprisingly powerful things. The other 80% of language features are important eventually, but not at first.

Or if you're studying physics, mastering Newton's laws, conservation principles, and basic calculus gives you the foundation to understand a vast range of phenomena. The exotic stuff can come later.

How do you identify this critical 20%? Look for concepts that:

And remember: the best material is often not the most advanced, but the most fundamental, explained with exceptional clarity. A brilliant explanation of a basic concept is worth far more than a mediocre explanation of an advanced one.

So before you dive into learning something new, take the time to find the right material—incremental, focused on fundamentals, and cutting straight to the heart of the matter. Your future self will thank you.

Spaced Repetition

Review information at increasing intervals to cement it in long-term memory.

Spaced repetition forgetting curve
Source: https://fs.blog/spacing-effect/

Our brains are leaky buckets. That's just how they work. You learn something today, and if you don't use it, most of it will be gone in a week. It's not a design flaw—it's a feature. Your brain is optimized to remember things that you use repeatedly and forget things you don't need.

So if you want to remember something long-term, you need to convince your brain that it's important. And the most efficient way to do that is to recall it just when you're about to forget it.

That's the essence of spaced repetition. It's not complicated, but it is powerful. Here's how it works:

Learn something new. Then review it after about a day. If you remember it well, wait longer before the next review—maybe 3 days. If you still remember it then, wait even longer—perhaps a week. Each time you successfully recall the information, increase the interval before the next review.

This works because each time you recall something just as it's fading, you strengthen the neural pathways. It's like exercise for your memory—the struggle to recall makes the memory stronger, just as the strain of lifting weights makes your muscles stronger.

The beautiful thing about spaced repetition is its efficiency. Traditional studying often involves reviewing everything multiple times, whether you know it well or not. With spaced repetition, you focus your time on what you're about to forget, and spend less time on what you already know well.

You can implement this with simple flashcards, reviewing them at increasing intervals. But in my opinion, what is much stronger is building repetition into one's life with community, projects or writing. You can also use software like Anki that automatically schedules reviews based on how well you knew each card.

But here's a key insight: spaced repetition works best for atomic facts or small concepts that can be recalled in a single moment. For complex skills or interconnected knowledge, you need to combine it with other techniques like deliberate practice or teaching.

And remember—the goal isn't just to memorize facts. It's to build a foundation of knowledge that's so solid you don't have to think about it. When the basics are automatic, your working memory is freed up to focus on the novel, creative aspects of whatever you're doing.

That's why musicians practice scales, why mathematicians memorize formulas, and why pilots memorize emergency procedures. Not because memorization is the goal, but because it's the foundation that makes higher-level thinking possible.

Regular Self-Testing

Challenge yourself frequently to identify gaps in understanding and strengthen recall.

There's a peculiar quirk in how we learn: we're terrible at judging what we know. We confuse familiarity with understanding, recognition with recall, and exposure with mastery. It's like thinking you can play basketball because you've watched a lot of games.

This is where testing yourself comes in. Not as punishment, not as assessment, but as a powerful learning tool.

When you test yourself, several remarkable things happen. First, you get an honest signal about what you actually know versus what you think you know. It's the difference between saying "Oh yeah, I know that" when you see a concept, and actually being able to explain it from scratch.

Second, the very act of retrieving information strengthens your ability to recall it later. This is called the "testing effect" or "retrieval practice," and it's one of the most robust findings in cognitive science. The mental effort of pulling something from memory makes that memory stronger and more accessible next time.

Third, testing reveals exactly where your understanding breaks down. Maybe you can solve simple problems but struggle with complex ones. Maybe you know the facts but can't connect them. These gaps would remain invisible if you just reviewed your notes.

How should you test yourself? There are many ways:

The key is to make it challenging but not impossible. If you can't recall anything, it's too hard. If you can answer without thinking, it's too easy. The sweet spot is where you struggle a bit but eventually succeed.

And remember: getting things wrong when you test yourself isn't failure—it's information. It tells you exactly what you need to focus on next. In fact, some research suggests that failing to retrieve something and then learning the correct answer leads to stronger memory than simply studying it in the first place.

So don't wait until the night before an exam to test yourself. Make it a regular part of your learning process, and watch your understanding deepen and solidify.

Learning Habits and Streaks

Create consistent patterns of study that become automatic and self-reinforcing.

Learning habits and streaks illustration

We are not primarily creatures of reason and willpower. We are creatures of habit. Most of what you do today, you'll do tomorrow, and the next day, and the day after that. This can work against you—or it can be your greatest ally in learning.

The secret is to build learning habits so strong that they feel strange to break. When this happens, continuing to learn takes less willpower than stopping.

Think about brushing your teeth. You don't debate whether to do it each night or calculate the long-term benefits. You just do it, because not doing it would feel wrong. That's the power of habit.

One of the most effective ways to build a learning habit is through streaks—unbroken chains of days where you practice, even if just a little. There's something psychologically powerful about not wanting to break the chain.

Here's how to build effective learning streaks:

First, make it ridiculously small to start. Don't commit to studying for two hours daily—commit to opening your book for just five minutes. The key is consistency, not intensity. You can always do more once you've started, but the habit needs to be so easy you can do it even on your worst days.

Second, attach it to an existing habit. Study right after your morning coffee, or just before your evening shower. This creates a trigger that reminds you automatically.

Third, track your streak visibly. My favorite way to do this, by far, is Google Sheets. Share it with a friend, color-code your wins, and flexibly add more goals as you go. But feel free to use any method you like: cross off days on a calendar, use an app that shows your chain, or keep a learning journal. Make the streak itself rewarding to maintain.

Fourth, plan for failure. Decide in advance what happens if you miss a day. The rule might be "never miss twice in a row" or "if I miss a day, I do a shorter session the next day, but I still do something."

The beauty of this approach is that it works with human nature rather than against it. Instead of relying on motivation (which fluctuates) or willpower (which depletes), you're building automatic behaviors that carry you forward even when you don't feel like studying.

Remember: the greatest threat to mastery isn't lack of talent—it's inconsistency. Mastery is just a (thoughtful) 10,000 hours away. For more on this concept, watch this video on deliberate practice and the path to expertise.

Alternating Levels of Abstraction

Shift between big-picture thinking and detailed analysis to build comprehensive understanding.

Imagine you're trying to understand a forest. You could study it from a satellite view, seeing patterns of growth and the overall shape. Or you could examine a single leaf under a microscope, understanding its cellular structure. Both perspectives are valuable, but neither alone gives you complete understanding.

This is the power of alternating between levels of abstraction when learning. You need both the forest and the trees—and everything in between.

At the highest level of abstraction, you're asking: What's the big picture? How does this connect to other fields? What are the core principles? This gives you context and meaning, helping you see why the details matter.

At the lowest level, you're breaking concepts down to their simplest components. What are the fundamental building blocks? How exactly does this mechanism work? This gives you precision and clarity, ensuring your understanding isn't just vague handwaving.

The magic happens when you move between these levels, repeatedly. Start with the big picture to get oriented. Then dive into the details to build solid understanding. Then zoom back out to see how those details fit into the larger context. Then dive into a different set of details. Back and forth, like breathing in and out.

This approach works because knowledge isn't flat—it's hierarchical and networked. Concepts contain subconcepts, which contain further subconcepts. And everything connects laterally to related ideas.

Here's a concrete example: If you're learning about evolution, you might start with the big idea (species change over time through natural selection). Then examine the mechanisms in detail (genetic variation, inheritance, differential reproduction). Then zoom back out to see how evolution connects to other fields like geology, genetics, and ecology. Then dive into specific examples like the evolution of antibiotic resistance or the Galápagos finches.

This alternation helps you in several ways:

One practical technique is to decompose and recompose concepts. Take something complex, break it down to its simplest elements, understand each one thoroughly, and then rebuild the whole. This is like taking apart a watch, examining each gear and spring, and then reassembling it. Once you've done this, you don't just know what the watch looks like—you understand how it works.

Additional Pedagogy Candidates

Techniques that, while not in the top tier of impact, are still valuable additions to your learning toolkit.

The methods described above represent some of the most powerful learning techniques available. However, there's a rich ecosystem of additional approaches that, while perhaps not quite as universally impactful, can still significantly enhance your learning journey. These techniques are particularly valuable when tailored to your specific learning style, subject matter, or circumstances.

Consider experimenting with these approaches as supplements to the core methods:

The beauty of these additional techniques is that they can be mixed and matched according to your needs. Some may resonate strongly with your personal learning style, while others might be particularly well-suited to specific subjects or learning challenges. The key is experimentation—try different approaches, observe their effects on your learning, and gradually build a personalized toolkit that works for you.

Remember that learning how to learn is itself a skill—perhaps the most valuable meta-skill you can develop. By thoughtfully combining these techniques with the core methods described earlier, you can dramatically accelerate your learning in any domain.


Foundational Metalearning Curricula

Essential resources for developing your capacity to learn effectively in any domain.

If you're serious about developing your learning abilities to their fullest potential, these resources provide a comprehensive foundation. Each offers unique insights into the art and science of learning, from different but complementary perspectives.

This curated collection represents some of the most valuable works on learning how to learn—books and courses that have transformed the learning journeys of countless individuals:

These resources complement each other beautifully—some focus on the psychological aspects of learning, others on practical techniques, and still others on the habits and environmental factors that support deep learning. Together, they provide a comprehensive foundation for anyone serious about mastering the meta-skill of learning itself.

The journey to becoming an exceptional learner is itself a learning process. As you explore these resources, you'll likely find that some resonate more strongly with you than others. Trust this intuition—it's a sign that you're developing your own philosophy of learning, one that's tailored to your unique mind and circumstances.

Extended Metalearning Curriculum

Further resources for those seeking to deepen their understanding of learning and cognition.

Once you've explored the foundational resources, this extended curriculum offers additional perspectives and specialized approaches to learning, cognition, and performance. These works delve into specific aspects of mental development, from memory techniques to flow states, from cognitive biases to mindfulness practices.

This extended curriculum represents diverse approaches to learning and cognitive development. Some focus on specific techniques like memory systems or note-taking methods, while others address the psychological and philosophical foundations of effective learning. Still others examine the cognitive biases and limitations that can hinder our progress.

As with any curriculum, the goal isn't necessarily to read every book, but rather to explore the areas that most resonate with your learning style and current challenges. Each of these works offers valuable insights that can be integrated into your personal approach to learning and cognitive development.

Acknowledgements

This exploration stands on the shoulders of many brilliant minds and supportive communities.

This essay emerged through the collective wisdom of many: The Inspired Autodidacts Community (facebook.com/groups/inspiredautodidacts) for their experimental spirit; Lillian Tara of the Center for Educational Progress for the initial vision of reimagining education; Michael Tartre and Ivan Vendrov for their critical feedback that refined these ideas; Nielda Gagne and Lauren Moos for their accountability support; and the countless researchers whose empirical work on learning effectiveness forms the foundation of these approaches. Any insights belong to this broader community; any errors are entirely my own.